The Cathedral Effect: Why Your Startup Needs to Think Like a Master Builder

Startups are like roller coasters—everyone's in a rush to scale, ship, and satisfy faster than the competition. The pressure to move quickly is intense, and it can feel like you're always racing against time to deliver the next big feature or grab the next milestone. But if you're always chasing the next sprint without thinking about what you're building for the long term, you might be missing something crucial. I call it the "Cathedral Effect." Let's talk about why adopting a strategic, long-term mindset could be the difference between a company that fizzles out and one that becomes highly valuable, even if your goal is to exit in 5 to 10 years.

Stop Chasing the Short-Term High

Every entrepreneur knows the pressure of short-term market demands. Investors want to see growth, users want to see features, and your team wants to see quick wins. But here’s the truth: If you're always just reacting to the next customer request or the next competitor move, you’re not building anything substantial—you’re just patching holes.

Think about it this way: Would you rather be building a shack or a cathedral? Shacks go up fast. Cathedrals take years, sometimes generations. But which one becomes a monument that people admire for centuries? If your startup is always chasing the short-term high, you’re building a shack—quick satisfaction but zero legacy.

The Slow Build Is the Real Power Play

Great cathedrals weren’t built overnight. They were assembled stone by stone, with artisans who cared about every small detail—even the ones that no one would see. This is the "slow build" mentality that your startup should embrace. When you’re prioritizing features, don’t just think about what will get you a boost today. Think about how each feature connects to your overarching product vision. Every piece should fit into the bigger picture of what you’re creating.

Sure, it takes longer. Sure, it might mean some initial market opportunities get passed over. But the payoff comes when you realize that you’ve built something that can’t be easily replicated. The slow build is the true power play.

User Feedback vs. Visionary Foresight

User feedback is vital, but it's not all created equal. You need to balance user demands with visionary foresight. Some customers will come along for the ride because they share your broader vision for the product and understand its place in the industry. These are the customers whose feedback is most valuable—they see where you're headed and want to help you get there. The problem is, most startups have barely articulated their vision, let alone identified those critical customers who are willing to join them for the journey. Imagine if the builders of Notre Dame had taken a survey every week and adjusted their plans based on public feedback. You’d end up with a patchwork of styles, not a cohesive masterpiece. The same applies to product development—yes, listen to users, but focus on those who align with your vision. Keep your eyes on the ultimate goal of what you're creating.

Cultivate Patience in a World Obsessed with Speed

Patience is a rare commodity in the startup world, but it’s necessary. The "Cathedral Effect" is about cultivating a culture of patience, of understanding that anything great takes time. Resist the urge to make every decision about immediate gratification. Instead, focus on how each choice contributes to building a product that will last, that will mean something in five, ten, or twenty years.

Build a Team of Master Builders

Your team is the key to this mindset shift. Foster a sense of shared purpose and ownership. Just like the artisans who worked on cathedrals, who knew they were building something that would outlast them, your team should feel like they are contributing to a grander vision. Inspire your people to see beyond the next quarter and to take pride in laying a foundation for something enduring.

The Legacy Play

The tension between short-term market pressure and long-term visionary building is real. But it’s a tension you must learn to navigate if you want your product to leave a mark. Embrace the Cathedral Effect and you’ll find yourself not just building features, but building a legacy.

How to Apply the Tension Framework to Build Your Cathedral

To make the "Cathedral Effect" tangible, let's use the Tension Framework to guide your decision-making between short-term pressures and long-term goals. Here’s a simple framework to help:

1. Identify the Tension: Clearly outline the short-term market pressures versus your long-term product vision. This step requires you to write down both: What are the immediate asks from your users, investors, or market, and what is your ultimate long-term vision?

2. Define Your Symbols of Success: In the same way that cathedrals were adorned with symbols that conveyed their purpose, decide what symbols represent your long-term success. This could be user adoption metrics that align with the bigger vision, features that differentiate you for the long haul, or strategic partnerships that bolster credibility. The key is to make sure these symbols align with your legacy, not just the next quarter.

3. Determine the Short vs. Long-term Impact of Each Feature: Every feature you consider adding should be evaluated in terms of its impact. Does it add to the immediate satisfaction of the market, or does it lay a cornerstone for your cathedral? If it’s the former, make sure it doesn’t distract from the broader vision. If it’s the latter, understand how it will strengthen the foundation you're building.

4. Foster the Right Culture: Implement practices that encourage a "master builder" mindset in your team. For example, include "legacy value" as a criterion when evaluating product features or initiatives. Celebrate wins that contribute to long-term goals, not just immediate gains. Ensure everyone on your team understands how their work fits into the grander vision.

5. Communicate Both Sides of the Tension: Your team needs to understand why balancing short-term and long-term is essential. Acknowledge the pressures, but don’t lose sight of the legacy you're building. Make it a point to share with your team how today’s work fits into the bigger vision, how the stones they are laying contribute to an enduring structure.

By using this framework, you can systematically navigate the tension between urgency and legacy. You’ll avoid the trap of short-term thinking while still making strategic decisions that drive immediate progress.

Think about companies like Atlassian or HubSpot—B2B businesses that started small but grew into leaders by staying true to their vision. They didn't just add features to meet every short-term demand; they focused on systematically executing a larger plan that aligned with their core mission. Even if your ultimate goal is to exit, thinking about legacy allows you to build a company that will eventually be valued much higher—because the buyer will see how you are methodically bringing your vision to life.

So ask yourself: Are you just putting up walls, or are you building a cathedral?

Building the next iconic product isn’t about reacting to every short-term wave; it’s about laying each stone carefully, keeping your eyes on a structure that will be beautiful and strong for years to come. In your next sprint planning or feature discussion, think like a master builder—and resist the urge to just put up a shack.

Keep Reading