The $2M Mistake: When Discounting Kills Your Business 💀

Ever watch someone try to haggle at Porsche? It's like bringing a coupon to a Michelin-star restaurant. Not only will you fail spectacularly, but you'll also become that story the sales team tells at happy hour for the next decade.

Let me tell you about Alex. They ran a successful consulting firm and prided themselves on being "flexible" with pricing. One day, they gave a 20% discount to land a "whale" client. Fast forward three months: that whale had turned into a giant octopus, strangling their business with endless demands and introducing them to all their equally discount-hungry friends.

Speaking of horror stories, my friend's SaaS company tried the "growth at all costs" approach with aggressive discounting to hit their ARR targets. They ended up with a customer base full of bargain hunters who churned faster than a smoothie maker and then burned through their runway trying to replace them.

The Psychology of "Just This Once"

Here's what happens in your brain when you consider offering a discount:

• "It's just 10% off"

• "They might become a great reference"

• "It's better than losing the deal"

• "We can make it up in volume"

Know what your potential client's brain hears?

• "My prices are inflated"

• "I'm desperate for business"

• "I don't really believe in my value"

• "Everyone who paid full price is a sucker"

Why Discounting Is Like Bad Plastic Surgery

Everyone can tell you've done it, nobody wants to mention it, and it permanently changes how people see you.

When I was running my research firm, we had a competitor who became known as the "always-on-sale" option. They didn't go bankrupt – worse. They became the industry's Dollar Store. Every single sales call started with prospects asking about discounts before even hearing what they offered.

The Porsche Principle: How to Actually Structure Your Pricing

Stop thinking about discounts and start thinking about tiers and options. Porsche doesn't discount – they seduce you with choices:

• Base model: Still a freaking Porsche

• Sport package: Because why not be faster?

• Custom options: $2,000 for special paint? Sure!

Here's the genius part: Nobody feels bad about buying the base model (it's a Porsche!), and the expensive options make the mid-tier packages look reasonable.

Your Pricing Should Be Like a Boss Battle

Remember video games where the boss had multiple forms? That's your pricing strategy:

Form 1: Core Offerings

• Basic (Still awesome)

• Professional (Most popular, wink wink)

• Enterprise (Makes everything else look reasonable)

Form 2: Power-Ups

• Priority support

• Extra features

• Exclusive access

Form 3: Limited Editions

• Time-bound offerings

• Exclusive spots

• Special access

The Social Science Behind Why Discounting Makes You Look Desperate

When you discount, you're not giving a gift – you're signaling weakness. It's like a peacock missing half its feathers trying to do a mating dance. Not a good look.

Studies in behavioral economics show that:

• Perceived value drops faster than the discount percentage

• Recovery of original price positioning takes 3-4x longer than the discount period

• Future purchase decisions are anchored to the discounted price

How to Say No to Discount Requests (Without Being a Jerk)

Instead of discounts, offer choices:

1. "Here's our starter package that might better fit your budget"

2. "Let's look at spreading the investment over a longer period"

3. "What if we adjusted the scope to match your budget?"

My favorite response: "We don't discount our prices, but we can discount the scope."

The Million-Dollar Question

Every time you're tempted to discount, ask yourself: 

"Would Apple give a discount if someone asked?" 

"Does Mercedes have a coupon code?" 

"When was the last time you saw Rolex on sale?"

The Bottom Line

Here's the thing about discounting: It's like putting your business on a diet of energy drinks and chocolate bars. Sure, you might get a quick rush, but the crash is coming, and it's going to hurt.

Remember: Your pricing isn't just about numbers – it's about your position in the market, your confidence in your value, and yes, even your self-respect. So the next time someone asks for a discount, channel your inner luxury brand and gracefully point them to your tiering options.

After all, nobody ever became a category leader by being the cheapest option in town.

Keep Reading